Best New York Home Warranty Companies

Home warranties are becoming more and more popular as a growing number of people wants to protect their appliances and systems. Since there are so many home warranty companies on the market nowadays, making a choice can be tough. To help you decide, we made this list of the top providers in New York. Check it out for more info. is an independent professional comparison site supported by referral fees from the sites which are ranked on the site. The home warranty sites and Special Offers that we present are from companies from which receives compensation. This compensation impacts the ranking of the sites. Other factors, including our own opinions, your location and likelihood of signing up for the site, may also impact how the ranking of the sites appears to a particular user. cannot and does not present information about every home warranty provider or home warranty offer available. Close
Choice Home Warranty logo

Choice Home Warranty

Choice Home Warranty boasts extensive coverage and excellent support.

  • Waiting Period: 30 days
  • Service Fee: $60
  • Response Times: 24-48h
9.9Our Rating
9.7User Rating
Total Protect logo

Total Protect

Total Protect has affordable plans and works with 40,000+ contractors

  • Waiting Period: 30 days
  • Service Fee: $75, $100, $125
  • Response Times: 24-48h
9.8Our Rating
9.8User Rating
Select Home logo

Select Home Warranty

SelectHomeWarranty is ideal for homeowners looking for basic coverage.

  • Waiting Period: 30 days
  • Service Fee: $60
  • Response Times: 24-48h
9.8Our Rating
9.7User Rating
American Home Shield logo

American Home Shield

AHS is one of the best home warranty solutions on the market.

  • Waiting Period: 12-24h
  • Service Fee: $75, $100, $125
  • Response Times: 15 days
8.8Our Rating
9.0User Rating
HWA Home Warranty logo

HWA Home Warranty

HWA is a fantastic company that has been in the game for 20+ years.

  • Waiting Period: 30 days
  • Service Fee: $50-$100
  • Response Times: 24-48h
8.6Our Rating
8.7User Rating
365 Home Warranty Logo

365 Home Warranty

365 Home Warranty provides first-class warranty plans nationwide.

  • Waiting Period: 30 days
  • Service Fee: $75
  • Response Times: 48 hours
8.5Our Rating
8.7User Rating
Warranty Direct Logo

Warranty Direct

Warranty Direct is a long-standing and popular home warranty company.

  • Waiting Period: 30 days
  • Service Fee: $50, $75
  • Response Times: within 72 hours
7.6Our Rating
7.9User Rating
Square Trade Logo


SquareTrade provides protection plans for individual home appliances.

  • Waiting Period: 0 to 30 days
  • Service Fee: $0
  • Response Times: up to 5 business days
7.5Our Rating
7.2User Rating
The Home Service Club logo

The Home Service Club

  • Waiting Period:
  • Service Fee:
  • Response Times:
7.0Our Rating
6.9User Rating

User reviews of New York home warranty companies

  • Submitted By Mark Dixon, Syracuse, AHS

    I like to fix things around my house, but I don’t know how to fix everything. This is why my wife insisted that we purchase a home warranty. We chose AHS. The first time we called them, our fridge stopped working. The technician came and he was a real pro. I kept asking him all sorts of questions and he answered all of them. He fixed the fridge in 20 minutes and walked me through the entire process. They’re a cool company, maybe the support is not that great, but the techs are really amazing.

  • Submitted By Yuri Gordon, New Rochelle, Square Trade

    My mother put me up to this, I gotta be honest. She knows I can’t change a light bulb on my own, so she wanted to get me covered. She’s a real internet expert, although she’s 61, and she’s the one who found Square Trade online, checked everything and just emailed me a contract to sign. Two years passed and I must admit she was right, I don’t know what I’d do without Square warranty. They fixed my laptop, cell phone, and fridge, everything in less than 48 hours. I am really happy with how they work.

  • Submitted By Vera Baker, Mount Vernon, TotalProtect

    When I called them to fix my fridge, everything was fine. A guy came the next day, easily found the problem, and fixed it in like 15 minutes. But when I needed my plumbing fixed, they didn’t send anyone for days! I had to call them a million times! I guess you never know with this company, which is not something I particularly like. If I pay for high-quality service, I expect nothing less.

  • Submitted By Stacey Reid, Buffalo, Choice Home Warranty

    Choice is the worst, I don’t know what I was thinking! I feel like I’m giving random contractors very generous tips that I don’t want to give! Plus, I’m giving those tips without receiving any actual service!!!


State guide